As Georgia prepares, this week, to travel to Tuscaloosa, Mark Richt has made an interesting decision. For the first time in his time as Georgia's head coach, Richt has completely closed practice. The question, of course, is why? Is he worried that the all-seeing eye of Nick Saban will find a way to steal his game plan? Is this a clever way of making excuses for UGA's loss to South Carolina? Has all of the talk of Belichik's dirty deeds gotten to him? Is he just trying to instill in his players an "us against the world" mentality?
Or is he just paranoid?The Capstone Report, calls the decision cynical:
There can be little doubt the move is cynical. If, as Richt suggested, Georgia is always worried about people watching practice, then he would've already shuttered practice. Unless the Bulldogs are coming out in the Wishbone, what information could be gathered from watching practice that could not already be gathered from watching game film?
Most people know Georgia's problems (see offensive line film from South Carolina game). I'm sure a good football coach could deduce a few additional things from watching practice; however, is that the best use of time at this stage of the season?
Regardless, Richt's closure of practice is a cynical attempt to silence the howls of another disappointing season in Athens.
Most people know Georgia's problems (see offensive line film from South Carolina game). I'm sure a good football coach could deduce a few additional things from watching practice; however, is that the best use of time at this stage of the season?
Regardless, Richt's closure of practice is a cynical attempt to silence the howls of another disappointing season in Athens.
Georgia Sports Blog, as one might expect, has a more optimistic take:
Frankly, I like the move. You shut down one possible advantage your adversary might employ. It should increase the feeling of isolation and focus during practice. And, the writers shouldn't complain that much because all they get to see is warm ups and special teams anyway.
Whether you believe the move is a result of spying concerns or not, the timing of the move is great. We've got a young team going on the road for a pivotal game before a large audience. It's a great way to get that attitude of us against the world that seems to work so well for visiting teams.
Whether you believe the move is a result of spying concerns or not, the timing of the move is great. We've got a young team going on the road for a pivotal game before a large audience. It's a great way to get that attitude of us against the world that seems to work so well for visiting teams.
I say the answer's just not that simple. Most likely, the answer is some odd combination of all of those factors. As what is probably Georgia's biggest game to date, Richt almost certainly has some aces up his sleeve that we haven't seen yet.
His comments seem to suggest that he thinks that South Carolina knew a little too much, and he'd be stupid if he didn't try to keep that from happening this week. If he's really paranoid, he might be doing this to try to isolate rats within his own program.
I'm sure Richt also realizes the psychological impact this will have on the players, the media impact, and I don't think we can discount the fact that he and many others seem to impute a lot of malice to Saban's actions. Bottom line, though, is that this is a big game for both squads and both Richt and Saban are both good enough coaches that they don't need to cheat to win.

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
9-19-2007 @ 2:41PM
Brian said...
How silly of Richt. Georgia is one of the most mundane teams both offensively and defensively in all of football. They have almost nothing to show that hasn't been seen nor will they deviate from a very vanilla approach. It's just not in their DNA.
I'm guessing the reasoning is more to what Georgia Sports Blog suggests, creating isolation and focus (I guess?).
Reply
9-19-2007 @ 3:27PM
Charlie said...
So he shut down practice....not a big deal. They'll probably still cream Bama
Reply
9-19-2007 @ 3:27PM
Jennifer M said...
Good for him. I don't blame anyone for having a special tactic when dealing with Alabama. The University of Alabama's football department is not known for probity.
Reply
9-19-2007 @ 7:57PM
leon buckelew said...
Yeah, and Beamer had something to say about that too. Little deflection, perhaps? I dont really think there's anything in the offense everyone hasnt already seen. Cheap shot by Richt.
Reply
9-19-2007 @ 8:34PM
atidechick said...
This seems like a cheap shot at Saban. It also defintely shows a sense of fear and paranoia on Richt's part. Like Brian said, if you've never closed your practices before why start now? Wow, who would've thought a year ago, Georgia would fear Alabama! Ha! ROLL TIDE!!
Reply
9-20-2007 @ 3:25AM
rowefork said...
UGA wins a close one.
Reply
9-21-2007 @ 5:36PM
Pete Woolsey said...
There have already been two other teams this year that have notched up wins against Bama before the games was ever play.
Reply
9-21-2007 @ 5:53PM
Charlie said...
i'm not a Georgia fan, Auburn and the two just don't mix. But Georgia is smart. Bama isn't known for being the school with the most character.
Reply