FanHouse

Can We Stop Pretending Adam Vinatieri Is a Good Kicker?


Let's just make sure we all understand something: Adam Vinatieri is not a good kicker. He used to be, a few years ago, although even then he was overrated because he was on a good team that gave him lots of opportunities to kick in big games.

But now he's not good. He's not average, either. he's bad.

It's not just the fact that he missed two field goals in tonight's 23-21 loss to the Chargers, including a 29-yarder that would have given the Colts the lead with less than two minutes to play. It's the fact that he's horrible on kickoffs. It's the fact that he hasn't made a 50-yard field goal in five years. It's the fact that the Colts have no more reason to be confident in Vinatieri right now than they would have if they brought back -- gasp -- Mike Vanderjagt.

Throw in the fact that Vinatieri is the highest-paid kicker in the league, and there isn't a single team in the league getting less bang for the buck out of the kicker position than the Colts. Please, football media of the world. Stop pretending Adam Vinatieri is a good kicker.

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)