FanHouse

Steelers Coach Mike Tomlin Questioned for Two-Point Conversion Calls vs. Jaguars

With 10:25 remaining in Saturday's Pittsburgh Steelers-Jacksonville Jaguars playoff game, the Steelers scored a touchdown to make the score 28-23, Jacksonville. Steelers coach Mike Tomlin decided to go for two and bring his team to within a field goal.

The initial play call -- a pass to Hines Ward -- worked, and the Steelers appeared to be within 28-25. But the Steelers were called for holding, meaning they now had to attempt it again from the 12-yard line. That time, quarterback Ben Roethlisberger tried to run it in and was stopped short.

Later in the fourth quarter the Steelers scored another touchdown to go up 29-28, and they went for two again and failed again. The final score, of course, was 31-29 Jaguars, meaning if the Steelers had kicked the extra points after both scores, the game would have gone into overtime.

So was Tomlin wrong? That's what all the Sunday morning quarterbacks are asking.


My feeling is this: Tomlin was right to try the two-point conversion the first time around, when the Steelers were down five. Getting to within a field goal late in a close game is huge. But once the Steelers were moved back by the holding penalty, Tomlin should have realized how much harder it is to make a conversion from 12 yards back than from two yards back, and sent in the kicker to for the extra point and bring the score to within 28-24.

Obviously, it's a lot easier to say that the next morning than it is to have your team ready to do it at the time, but good coaches need to have their teams ready for every possibility. Tomlin is a good coach, but he screwed up there, and it cost his team.

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Fantasy Football
ADVERTISEMENT