Posts tagged JoshMcCown at FanHouse

You've got questions. I've got answers. If not, I'll make them up. Each Thursday at 1 p.m. EST, I answer your queries on all things related to the NFL. If you have a question, send it over to NFLMailbag@aol.com. Don't forget to include your name and location. Click here for the archives. Rock'n'roll.

I know that this feature is slated to run on Thursdays, thus making this a day late. The Thursday season opener threw things off this week, but the mailbag will be running every Thursday from here on out. I wasn't hung over and I didn't forget. OK, I was a little hung over. Anyways ...

Was it a good move for the Carolina Panthers to dump Brett Basanez, a QB who'd been with the team for some time, knew the offense, and was relatively young with some upside, and instead bring in Josh McCown, who very well may be a decent backup but shouldn't be starting in this league, whereas Basanez possibly could have one day been a starter?
- SoulCitySigma1914, Greensboro, NC

Basanez did make a solid impression entering this year after two years mostly on the Panthers' practice squad, enough that a few teams gave him a look when the Panthers released him. That being said, the Panthers have a "project" quarterback that they like in Matt Moore, and they want to win now. Jake Delhomme is no sure thing, performance- or health-wise, so the Panthers probably wanted a backup with game experience who could come in if needed without disturbing too much. Basanez isn't that guy. Neither is Moore. Plus, I have to say, I've always liked McCown. Though four teams disagree. But what do they know? One of them was the Raiders ...

On Friday, the Dolphins sent quarterback Josh McCown to the Panthers, presumably to provide depth behind Jake Delhomme after Matt Moore suffered what looked to be a serious injury during the preseason finale against the Steelers (turns out, Moore will be okay and, like the rest of us, is day to day).

Prior to moving McCown, there was some speculation that Miami would either trade or release John Beck, the team's 2007 second-round pick. After all, Beck was drafted by the previous regime, and Bill Parcells himself had green-lighted the McCown signing, which included $2.5 million in up-front loot.

Funny story. According to the Palm Beach Post's Edgar Thompson, general manager Jeff Ireland has a perfectly rational explanation for keeping Beck and jettisoning McCown.

At least the Ravens didn't wait until the last minute. Kyle Boller's bum shoulder could put his season in jeopardy, and Troy Smith's Level 5 tummyache forced him to miss the final two preseason games. Which meant that rookie first-round pick Joe Flacco was the depth chart.

Baltimore signed backup Casey Bramlet long enough to cut him, but they're still in the market for a longer-term solution behind whoever ends up winning the starting job.

Ideally, Smith would be ready to go this week and Flacco would get comfortable holding a clipboard for the '08 season as the No. 3 option. One problem: with Boller's future in doubt, the team doesn't have a veteran backup. Luckily, plenty of semi-qualified names hit the open market yesterday, which is potentially good news for the Ravens.

The Miami Dolphins have traded quarterback Josh McCown to the Carolina Panthers, Fox Sports is reporting.

There is no word on what compensation the Dolphins got for McCown, but it couldn't have been much, considering that they were probably going to release him before tomorrow's mandatory roster cut-down.

The Dolphins gave McCown a $2.5 million signing bonus this year, but when they acquired Chad Pennington they no longer had need for the veteran as a backup. In Carolina he'll serve as a backup to Jake Delhomme; a backup to Delhomme became a more pressing need for Carolina when Matt Moore was hurt.

The move apparently means that John Beck's job is safe in Miami.

As the world quit spinning to watch Brett Favre take the field with the Jets for the first time last night, another quarterback was making his debut with a new team. Coincidentally, it was the same guy that was run out of New York to make room on the roster for The World's Most Selfish Player.

Yep, Chad Pennington started for the Dolphins, and for all the fanfare surrounding Favre, Pennington had just as impressive an outing in Miami.

Chad Pennington got off on the right foot with his new Dolphins teammates, completing 5-of-6 passes for 55 yards and a 104.9 quarterback rating while playing into the second quarter. After missing on his first throw, Pennington completed his final five and led the Dolphins to their first touchdown drive of the exhibition season

Rookie second-rounder Chad Henne took over for Pennington in the second quarter and played the rest of the game. Which means that John Beck and Josh McCown, quarterbacks Nos. 3 and 4 depending on who's making out the depth chart, didn't get off the bench.

PFT speculates that the Dolphins will keep McCown, signed during the Bill Parcells regime, and cut/trade Beck, who was drafted by Randy Mueller and Cam Cameron. The Palm Beach Post's Ben Volin writes that both McCown and Beck participated in the quarterbacks meetings after each offensive possession, "but Beck mostly stood by himself on the sidelines."

No idea what that means other than Beck seems to be very, very sad.

Yesterday I mentioned that Dolphins' quarterbacks Josh McCown and John Beck, two guys battling for the starting job just a week ago, got zero reps in practice during the 7-on-7 drills. Hardly a big deal since Chad Pennington was being force-fed a new offense in the hopes that he would be ready for the upcoming preseason game.

Despite what head coach Tony Sparano might say, it's pretty clear Pennington is the the guy going forward, at least until rookie Chad Henne is ready to assume full-time duties.

Which means that McCown and Beck probably won't be in Miami -- one way or the other -- when the season begins in three weeks.

Former Tennessee Titans general manager Floyd Reese, now with ESPN, said the notion of the Dolphins keeping four quarterbacks is ''unrealistic and outrageous'' and believes they will get only a late-round pick for Josh McCown or John Beck, if that. ''I wouldn't think they would have much value,'' he said. Miami reportedly will gauge trade interest in both but is on the hook for McCown's $2.5 million signing bonus if he is traded or cut.

Hindsight and all that, but you can't blame the Dolphins front office for signing McCown this offseason. Brett Favre was "retired" and the Jets' asking price for Pennington was presumably higher than what it was once they acquired Favre.

Yesterday, Dolphins head coach Tony Sparano was trying to convince us that Chad Pennington hadn't been given the starting job. You know, competition, team spirit and all that.

Well, during this morning's practice, in an effort to foster said competition, quarterbacks Josh McCown and John Beck took zero snaps during 7-on-7 drills to give Pennington a chance to learn the offense. So although neither player got an opportunity to actually, um, compete, in terms of mental reps, they were killing it. Too bad mental reps don't lead to playing time.

In any event, according to the Miami Herald's Armando Salguero, it looks like the Dolphins' future will be in the capable(?) hands of Pennington and Chad Henne:

Basically, the Dolphins are showing their hand with the Chads. Or as Dolphins GM Jeff Ireland calls them, "Penny and Henne." One is the Mr. Right Now. The other one seems like Mr. Right for the longterm future of the team. Coach Tony Sparano said it is pretty obvious that Pennington will play versus Jacksonville Saturday evening. I would imagine, based on the work so far this week, either he or Henne would start.

So where does this leave Josh and John? There has been speculation that Beck, one year after Miami drafted him in the second round, could be cut. McCown, on the other hand, will probably stick around, primarily because he has an uncanny ability to avoid the turk. It's a gift, really.

In the meantime, the Dolphins might want to think about finding somebody for Penny/Henne to throw to.

Huh. This is, well, totally not believable. Dolphins head coach Tony Sparano wants to make it clear that newly acquired quarterback Chad Pennington will not be given the starting gig. You know, because, Josh McCown and John Beck looked so competent in training camp that the team couldn't move to sign Pennington fast enough.

In any event, that's the spin coming out of Dolphins World Headquarters:

While many think Pennington's eight seasons of experience should make him an instant starter, the way the Dolphins' coaches and front office preach competition it's more likely he'll have just as arduous a road to earning the starting spot as Henne, Josh McCown or John Beck.

"Chad is going to be competing. He knows that," said Sparano, who last week complained about not having enough snaps to get a good look at the team's three quarterbacks.

Um, sure. Look, I appreciate trying to keep up the appearance of fairness, competition and all that, but if Pennington's sitting on the bench come Week 1, the Dolphins' quarterback situation is far worse than any of us realized.

Sparano added that Pennington "has the most experience in the room and I hope that he's going to be a mentor in that room for some of the younger guys," something Brett Favre, the guy who forced Pennington out in New York, didn't willingly embrace.

Sparano also indicated that the Dolphins could carry four quarterbacks, which seems like overkill until you realize that it could be a necessary evil given the perils of playing behind that offensive line.Whatever, here's to hoping they win the season opener for strictly schadenfreude-tastic reasons.

The NFL forces every team to come up with a depth chart before every game ... even exhibition ones. So Miami complied and listed Josh McCown as their #1 quarterback.

Well, for now.

"The depth chart is something I know you guys will make a lot out of but I don't make much of it right now,'' head coach Tony Sparano said. "It's something we had to produce and put out there, so we put it our there. That depth chart you have in your hand won't be the same this afternoon or tomorrow. It's going to change every single day.''

When further pressed for the reason why McCown, a seven-year veteran, was listed over John Beck, a second-year player, and Chad Henne, Sparano stressed it had more to do with experience than with their performance so far.

None of the quarterbacks have looked very good in camp, so picking McCown is the easy way out. McCown has 31 starts under his belt; Beck has four and Henne is a rookie.

Again, if this is how you determine your QB depth chart ... you have no QB.

Training camp can get old fast. What with the two-a-days (anybody still do that?), the oppressive heat, and all the tackling. It all get to be a bit much, frankly. Luckily, football czar/de facto owner/mentor Bill Parcells has found a way to break up the monotony: bring former Cowboys quarterback (and current Arena League sensation) Quincy Carter in for a workout.

If nothing else, it'll distract the players from their current situation, and more importantly, remind them that there are other, less fortunate souls trying to find our way in this world.

Michael Irvin reported the "news" on his radio show yesterday, so take that for what it's worth. But if Carter is given a try out, what, exactly, does that say about the current state of the Dolphins QB depth chart? Word on the street had Josh McCown as the early leader, what with Chad Henne just signing his contract and John Beck getting off to a "disastrous" start.

But are things so dire that Carter needs to called in? Good Lord, it's worse than I thought.

Of course, maybe Parcells is just reaching out to a former player, something he's fond of doing. Or maybe he thinks Carter still can play -- he did quarterback the Cowboys to their improbable 2003 playoff appearance. Plus, compared to other ganja lovers on the team, Carter's virtually a saint. At least according to Carter.