Posts tagged SteveMcNair at FanHouse - AOL Sports Blog

The Word:

Pro Football Hall of Fame Class of 2013 Could be the Greatest!

This week we saw Michael Strahan and Jonathan Ogden retire ... two men who will see their way into Canton, OH. One of the greatest offensive tackles and defensive ends in our time should both enter the Hall in 2013.

If'n that weren't the only guys on that list.

Add in a certain guy by the name of Brett Favre (who now owns most of the quarterback records), Larry Allen and Warren Sapp ... not to mention the possibility of Junior Seau ... and and we could have one of the best classes in HoF history.

There are even a few fringe guys like Steve McNair, Rod Smith, Bryant Young and Priest Holmes who will get some love, but probably won't make it in -- at least not in '13.

But what a class that could be? There is a cut-off of five inductees (not counting ones from the Senior Committee) that can go in a single year ... meaning a name or two won't make the cut. Favre, Strahan, Ogden, Sapp and Allen each have won a Super Bowl. They have all kinds of Pro-Bowls on their resumes and several have records to boot ... making them the five favorites to get in (Seau could push Sapp out of that loft).


If Matt Ryan's Gone, Ravens Could Trade Down and Take Chad Henne ... 10th Overall


That the Ravens could be in the business for a quarterback is hardly news; in fact, it would be more of a story if they finally settled on someone who could hold down the job for more than a year.

The position becomes more of an immediate need now that Steve McNair has retired, although Kyle Boller was just as (in)competent filling in for McNair for parts of last season.

Baltimore used a second-day pick on Troy Smith a year ago, but no one would be surprised if the team drafted Matt Ryan with the eighth-overall pick should he still be hanging around the Aaron Rodgers Memorial Green Room.

But ESPN's John Clayton writes that should Ryan be off the board, the Ravens will probably trade down and try to grab Chad Henne later on Day 1. Sounds about right until you read this:
Most draft experts believe Henne should go in the bottom of the first or the top of the second round, but it's not out of the question for the Ravens to consider him as high as the 10th pick.
Number 10. Hmm. Two things: first the Ravens have a pretty spotless track record when it comes to evaluating talent, and it's hard to criticize their personnel decisions; second, their evaluative powers are rendered useless when it comes to drafting quarterbacks.

I can't imagine this actually happens, but if it does, look for Baltimore to re-draft Kyle Boller in the second round and then make a trade for Chris Redman. It would be only slightly less ludicrous than taking Henne tenth overall, I think.

Is Steve McNair a Hall of Famer?

When Steve McNair retired last week, it became inevitable that his candidacy for Canton would be evaluated. His trip from Alcorn State to the Super Bowl erased the last lingering doubts about the fitness of black quarterbacks and he threw for 31,304 yards in his career.

That's a nice number but it's also less than Kerry Collins. He only threw for 20 touchdowns three times, though, and the Titans went to the Super Bowl on Eddie George's legs and a strong defense more than McNair's right arm. They also didn't win that game, falling a yard short of forcing overtime and that may be the defining yard of McNair's chances at enshrinement. Hailed as a tough-as-nails gamer around the league, McNair with a ring would be a much more appealing candidate than without one.

Hashmarks spoke with one HOF voter who is keeping an open mind about McNair's chances, though.
"I can't say that I would never vote for McNair. There are some guys like Warren Moon that I didn't think was a Hall of Famer at first, but as time passed, the numbers stood out and I was convinced that he was."
That's a hard case to make given McNair's era. Peyton Manning, Tom Brady and Brett Favre are guaranteed spots in Canton and there's likely to be one or two others coming from behind that will surpass McNair's modest overall resume. McNair isn't a HOFer right now and time isn't likely to help him much either.

Steve McNair Retired Because John Harbaugh Hates Fat People


The days of the fat quarterback appear to be numbered: first Jared Lorenzen is replaced by that dreamboat, Mittens Carr, and now Steve McNair up and retires. The obvious reason for McNair calling it quits is because he's been beaten to a pulp for 13 consecutive seasons, but the decision may have more to do with his weight than his health.

According to the Baltimore Sun's Mike Preston, the oft-injured 35-year-old had every intention of coming back for 2008, but new head coach and resident hard-ass John Harbaugh might've had other ideas. Indirectly, anyway:
Harbaugh scheduled minicamps almost every other week throughout the summer. He wanted regular attendance by players during the offseason weight-lifting program. He wanted McNair to lose weight because he had ballooned to 250 pounds since the season ended.

There is a new work ethic on the Ravens, and McNair basically said yesterday, thanks, but no thanks.
McNair has never been known as a practice guy, but one Titans coach told Preston that "there is not one player in the league I'd rather have on my team on Sundays. That's when he puts on the Superman cape." Which, apparently, needs to be let out a little in the neck.

It's hard to blame Harbaugh for doing exactly the opposite of what ultimately got Brian Billick fired. And if toughening up minicamps and training camps gets the team a little younger in the process, well, that's not all bad either. Derrick Mason, Samari Rolle and Trevor Pryce probably disagree.

Baltimore Ravens QB Steve McNair Retires


Baltimore Ravens quarterback Steve McNair will announce his retirement at a news conference at team headquarters this afternoon. The news was reported on NFL Network and is on the Ravens' official web site.

The news comes as a surprise; the Baltimore Sun reported today that McNair is "hoping to keep his 13-year NFL career going after a turnover-marred, injury-filled 2007."

McNair has had a great career, making three Pro Bowls and winning the league MVP award in 2003. A Division I-AA player in college who was seen as something of a risk when the Houston Oilers made him their first-round draft pick in 1995, McNair developed into one of the best quarterbacks of his generation.

But in recent years he has suffered through injuries and has been ineffective. He played in just six games in 2007, and he might not have been the Ravens' starter if he had returned this year.

Steve McNair: I Expect to Start Next Season

The Baltimore Ravens are one of the hardest teams to figure entering the offseason. They're coming off a terrible season and hired John Harbaugh to be their head coach. Usually, these are the times for radical overhauls of roster and staff. Harbaugh kept several of Brian Billick's assistants, though, and the Ravens are larded with veterans who aren't going anywhere, especially on defense.

But quarterback, that's one place where a change is coming, right? The Ravens got nothing from that position in '07 and, with the eighth pick in the draft, it's gotta be time to start all over again. Not if Steve McNair has anything to say about it.
"Old, yep. They said the same thing about John Elway and then he went on to win two championships after he got old. Look at Brett Favre. They said he was old, and he came back and did what he did this year. I still think I can play at a high level, and I think we're still going to be a very good football team again."

People did say Elway and Favre were old, but neither one ever played as poorly or suffered as many injuries as McNair. The only reason to bring McNair back is if you think you can win right away and think McNair can manage a winning offense. That's the problem with heading in two directions at once. The age of the Ravens roster says win now but the talent says we've got to rebuild.

The Ravens Need a QB, but It Doesn't Mean They'll Find Him in the Draft

During this morning's marathon session of ESPN's Sunday Countdown, Chris Mortensen reports that the Ravens could be in the Donovan McNabb business this off-season. Mortensen does point out that McNabb thinks he'll be in Philly next year, but says that the "Baltimore Ravens are seriously pondering a play for McNabb, meaning their first-round pick -- No. 8 overall -- would have to be included in any trade proposal."

I think McNabb gets a bum wrap, and still think he's one of the top-10 quarterbacks in the league. That said, he's had trouble staying injury-free the last few seasons, and at 31, he's probably only got three or four high-level years left. Is that worth the eighth-overall pick? I don't think so, especially when the Ravens only had to give up a fourth-rounder for a much-closer-to-the-end-of-his-career Steve McNair. But Baltimore general manager Ozzie Newsome might feel differently.

Mortensen also reports that Derek Anderson could be a potential target. This assumes, of course, that Anderson doesn't sign a long-term deal, and ends up getting tendered the highest restricted-free-agent offer. Acquiring Anderson would then cost the Ravens a first- and third-round pick, which seems kind of steep for a player the team drafted in the sixth round a few years ago.

Mortensen also says that Anderson is an attractive choice because he's currently running an offensive scheme that Cam Cameron will install in Baltimore. Ultimately, I don't think the Ravens will make a serious run at either player -- the cost is too prohibitive -- but if the crop of draft-eligible quarterbacks disappoints at the combine and in their personal workouts, this could change.

NFL Offseason Roadmap: Baltimore Ravens

NFL Offseason Roadmap is a series focused on the needs of NFL teams as they begin the offseason.

The Baltimore Ravens have already taken their first step toward 2008. John Harbaugh is the new coach and brings with him the expectation of a more disciplined team that takes better advantage of its resources. Some have argued that this team is close to playoff position but, truthfully, change is needed to restore this team to the level of a contender. As it has for years, the major obstacle for the Ravens to overcome is at football's marquee position.

1. Quarterback
Elvis Grbac. Randall Cunningham. Jeff Blake. Chris Redman. Kyle Boller. Anthony Wright. Steve McNair. Those are the men who have started at quarterback for the Ravens since Trent Dilfer won Super Bowl XXXV in 2001. Other than McNair in 2006, not a one of them has done anything to earn a second season on the job, and McNair went down in flames in year two. Boller didn't embarrass himself at the end of this season but he didn't do anything to warm the cockles of your heart either.

Billick was Boller's biggest champion and we don't know who will be running the offense in 2008, so it's anybody's guess as to who will be under center.

Merril Hoge Doesn't Want You to Forget: Vince Young Is Not Very Good



Merril Hoge hasn't exactly been reserved in his criticism of Titans quarterback Vince Young. Basically, he thinks Tennessee drafted the wrong guy in 2006, and now the organization is having to deal with the repercussions.

Young had a solid rookie campaign, assuming the starting job midway through the season, and guiding the Titans to an 8-8 record. In 2007, though, Young tossed 17 picks and only nine touchdowns, and struggled with consistency when he wasn't battling injuries. And now that offensive coordinator Norm Chow has been canned, Hoge takes again takes aim at Young:

Vince Young's Quadriceps Injury Could Become Chronic

Though Titans coach Jeff Fisher is optimistic about quarterback Vince Young playing against the Chargers, I'm not sure why he should be. He claims that the quadriceps injury hasn't been an issue for Young since the Houston game. Color me highly skeptical given the public information out there about Young's injury.

Quad injuries are ones that athletes can keep re-injuring because they don't cause pain until maximum exertion, like when all out sprinting. This is what I wrote when I (correctly) predicted that Young wouldn't play against the Texans in their first matchup:
Don't take my word for it, this doctor guy says that re-injury to the quad is a real possibility. Also the less time the injury has to heal, the more likely that re-injury could occur, or perhaps a worse injury. Even a basic look-see on the internet has tons of stories of these sorts of quad injuries gone bad. Like this one:
ADVERTISEMENT