| No. | Team | Pick | Pos. |
|---|
| Why this guy: - So, I took Tomlinson. The appropriate reaction from the rest of you would be to just quit right now, because Team McLovin domination is assured. |
| Herrera says: - Can't go any other way. LDT is the first pick. It's a no-brainer and you'd be laughed at if you didn't take him. |
| You say: - I believe LT2 for MJD will lead him to this year's title. - BootsyLD / The same exact thing was said about Ricky Williams and after Ricky broke the TD record he never had a good season after that. Tomlinson is going to end up the same way, you can take my word on that and when he does suck, I say they trash mighty MJD. - dallas4life04 |
| Why this guy: - The U baby! He's got heart! |
| Herrera says: - Definitely surprising pick at No. 2. Steven Jackson was the pick here. Gore's still dealing with a hand injury and I think his physical style may catch up with him this year. |
| You say: - Frank Gore may have heart, but heart won't stop an injury-plagued year. - wvudanks |
| Why this guy: - Sitting in my chair with the first frosty brew of the day in my hand, torn between LJ and Addai, Steven Jackson falls to me at #3. I will take it with no complaints! |
| Herrera says: - Action Jackson falls right into D.J.'s lap (not literally). He was my No. 2 pick without question. |
| You say: - Jackson at pick three is a gift from the fantasy gods. - bootsyld |
| Why this guy: - I'm not too optimistic about L.J. after his holdout and past heavy workload, but I just can't pass him up. |
| Herrera says: - Questions abound for L.J. with rust, weakened O-line, and new QB - but Herman Edwards will pound him for another gigantic workload. Good pick here. |
| You say: - LJ will be just fine. He's been working his butt off in Arizona. - BootsyLD / I like the reference to Art Monk. I still can't believe the guy has not made it into the Hall of Fame. Just look at his career stats. - hightower94 |
| Why this guy: - Love Addai's upside another year in the colts system. He is younger, stronger version of Edge James. |
| Herrera says: - I can't disagree with that. Many would have opted for Shaun Alexander here, but I'm an Addai lover as well. |
| You say: - Addai should be a top 5 running back at seasons end. Great pick! - emmit8422 |
| Why this guy: - I don't like to take QBs in the first round, but Peyton is a beast. I don't care about his playoff schedule. |
| Herrera says: - First surprise of the draft. This league does give 1 pt. per 20 pass yards and 6 pt. for TD, so it's justified, but I still think it's a bit too high. |
| You say: - In a 6 pt per TD league, Peyton Manning is absolutely the pick at 6. Or anywhere in the first round. - bootsyld |
| Why this guy: - Over 1,700 total yds.last season. TD production has improved every year. |
| Herrera says: - I like the pick, F.W.P. is very solid here and I think he will have even a bigger role in the passing game this year. |
| You say: - |
| Why this guy: - this draft is officially over ... "Down goes Frazier." |
| Herrera says: - I like Bulger a lot, but I am stunned. My jaw is still agape just like Frazier's was after he hit the canvas. |
| You say: - Drafting Bulger 9th is like drafting Josh McRoberts before Kevin Durant - wvudanks / I still cant tell whos the bigger retard. The chick who took Frank Gore or the guy that took Bulger? Ok...its Bulger. I wish you were in my league pal. - bigtime93 / Bulger, Bulger!! Are you legally retarded? You're banned from fantasy football. - lagbsportsfeind |
| Why this guy: - I wanted Peyton Manning, but no luck there. I may be lucky getting Alexander with 9th pick if gets back to '05 form - he's right there with LT and LJ. |
| Herrera says: - Alexander's should be refreshed and fell into his lap all the way down at No. 9. Nice pick. |
| You say: - I would have loved to get Alexander at 9 in my draft - jim99mo |
| Why this guy: - Yeah, he always seems to be on the "questionable" list every friggin' week, but I can't doubt the guy's versatile ability to pile on the yardage, and McNabb's back. |
| Herrera says: - |
| You say: If Herrera comments on pick #10, does the world implode? - burtwest2001 |
| Why this guy: - Solid performer and will make it through the season without an arrest. |
| Herrera says: - I can't guarantee the no-arrest part, but you can't go wrong with Rudi here. Rock solid. |
| You say: - Rudi will put up nice numbers this year, as will all the Bengals...excluding the defense - wvudanks |
| Why this guy: - I've got the 12-13 picks in two AOL drafts so far ... My vengeance will be Sundays....But someone is still getting fired. |
| Herrera says: - Nice pick at No. 12, I'm drinking the Koolaid a bit too. High expectations for Maroney as the sole Pats back. |
| You say: Maroney should be fine but how fine with Brady's new toys? - yamaharider1228 |
