| No. | Team | Pick | Pos. |
| Why this guy: - I've got Tomlinson and two stud wideouts. I'll be starting Slappy White as my 2nd RB, but that's alright. |
| Herrera says: - I think MJD owes himself some SchruteBucks for that Slappy White name drop. He's cleaned up on wideouts nicely and maybe he knows a couple of good sleeper backs later. |
| You say: - |
| Why this guy: - The U No. 3. Peyton will find him enough times again. |
| Herrera says: - What can I say, she loves her players from the U. Wayne isn't a bad pick here, especially with receivers likely to thin out when it gets back around. |
| You say: - |
| Why this guy: I got my stud RBs. Time to grab a WR and Holt is certainly at the top of my board. I like how this is going so far.... |
| Herrera says: - Big play Holt looked like he was wearing down a bit last year, but he's Bulger's unquestioned No. 1 target downfield. Receivers going fast, solid pick. |
| You say: - |
| Why this guy: - Can't take T.O. or Fitzgerald because they have the same bye as L.J., so hello Javon! |
| Herrera says: - Love Javon Walker this year, but not in the 3rd round. Receiver run hitting full throttle. |
| You say: - |
| Why this guy: - Former Steeler coordinator Whisenhunt will use Boldin like Hines Ward. Big Play Guy! |
| Herrera says: - And another receiver. I like Boldin as a consistent wideout, but this is getting a bit nuts, don't you think? |
| You say: - |
| Why this guy: - The Lions should be throwing all over the place this season, and Roy Williams should be the top choice. |
| Herrera says: - Same thing with Boldin, I like Roy this year a lot now that he has a big-play threat aside him to draw attention, but there's still solid backs left. |
| You say: - |
| Why this guy: - Proven back with 1,200+ yd potential...preseason calf injury will heal. |
| Herrera says: - I like this pick a lot. Jets O-Line has some questions, but the offense can be dynamic and Jones is a proven workhorse. |
| You say: - |
| Why this guy: - You want the ball in his hands around the goal line. |
| Herrera says: - Softly spoken for the man who took Barber and Bulger with his other picks, but I like Deuce here, should be able to come close to last year's numbers. |
| You say: - |
| Why this guy: - I hate TO as much as anyone. But fantasy is all about the best stats and I need a WR. TO it is. |
| Herrera says: - Go back and look at last year's numbers for T.O. when Tony Romo was the starting QB. He was consistency king, in spite of the controversy hovering over him. |
| You say: T.O. at pick 33 is the steal of the draft, and at least 4 or 5 recievers too late in this draft. Come on...he's been no lower than #2 WR in stats per start for quite a few years running. - dtflchamps |
| Why this guy: - Starting running back not in a time share playing for a top team? I'll take in the third round, surprised he fell this far. |
| Herrera says: - You were better off with your boy Marshawn. Take a leap of faith for once in your life! |
| You say: - Herrera, those qualitiy backs will not outperform top flight receivers. Ronnie "Doo Doo" Brown is a bust. Give me Chad Johnson, Anquan Boldin, or Kevin Curtis any day. - bigsnapdawg1 |
| Why this guy: - Whosyourmomma - Palmer can't always throw to Johnson. |
| Herrera says: - Solid pick, and I was thinking about it. Housh is consistent as it gets and Palmer looks for him often in the red zone. |
| You say: - |
| Why this guy: - Zzzzzzzzzzz ... huh? ...BINGO! Oh, wrong game ...McNabb has killed for me before ...if he gets hurt ...someone's getting fired. |
| Herrera says: - Nice value pick here after people went bonzo for Brady and company in the second round. Injury questions, but he's the last top QB left. |
| You say: - Donovan McNabb- Half-Man, Half-A season. - guzmanlane |