Giants Need Reality Check

Regerrrr69 09:11:00 AM Dec 11 2007

NAME 1 GOOD MANNING THAT EVER PLAYED ARCHIE SUCKED PEYTON SUCKED ONLY WON A SUPER BOWL CAUSE OF A BAD CALL AGAINST THE PATS AND DONT DENY IT THE REFS SAID THEY WERE SORRY THEY BLEW IT AND U ALL THINK THE PATS GET THE CALLS AND THEN THERE IS ELI HE SUCKS THEN THERE IS THER MOM SHE SHOULD HAVE SUCKED THEN THOSE 2 IDIOTS WOULD NOT EVEN B HERE ILL BET THE WHOLE MANNING FAMILY SUCKS

Bkarate215 06:03:34 PM Dec 08 2007

Unfortunately, some Giant fans want to forgive and forget the blunder of drafting Eli. No, let’s not forget the past because it will surely repeat itself. The Giants have been a poor presence in the front office for years. How could they have given up a chance for Shawn Merriam for this country bumpkin? Want kind of back door dealings went on to get this so so guy. Not only should Coughlin go for his poor performance as a coach but to recognize this kid is not the answer (Kurt Warner). Hey Tiki Barber you were right about this kid he is as exciting as watching paint dry. He (Eli) should thank his stars his last name is Manning or he would be working at Wal-Mart in Mississippi and living off his college career victories. As for giving Eli leeway, the NFL is a performance driven business, enough said.

nygiantsfanLT56 07:56:00 PM Dec 04 2007

The Giants are one of the most prolific teams to beat in the NFC right now. Eli has played a mediocre game throughout the season, but if we want to beat the Cowboys, Eli has to step up. If a quarterback is doing well, the whole team will feel encouraged by him. If Eli would just get mad and show some emotion I wouldnt feel like he should be traded. Look at the Bears. Last year, Rex Grossman led them to the Super Bowl. He is a mediocre quarterback in terms of passing, but he shows emotion and doesnt duck and fall when he is touched by a defender. Eli just seems to give up. It's like he just wants to take a hit, and go home. The defense, and the running game has taken the load for the Giants.(3 goal line stands against the Bears.) I don't think that the legacy is hard to deal with at all. It's just in his head. He could be an amazing quarterback, just like his brother, if he picks apart defenses just like at Ole Miss. Its hard to forgive him, but he's the Giants quarterback and I have to

nygiantsfanLT56 07:55:00 PM Dec 04 2007

The Giants are one of the most prolific teams to beat in the NFC right now. They lead the NFC Wild Card with an 8-4 record. Most teams in first place don't have that record. Eli has played a mediocre game throughout the season, but if we want to beat the Cowboys, Eli has to step up. If a quarterback is doing well, the whole team will feel encouraged by him. If Eli would just get mad and show some emotion I wouldnt feel like he should be traded. Look at the Bears. Last year, Rex Grossman led them to the Super Bowl. He is a mediocre quarterback in terms of passing, but he shows emotion and doesnt duck and fall when he is touched by a defender. Eli just seems to give up. It's like he just wants to take a hit, and go home. The defense, and the running game has taken the load for the Giants.(3 goal line stands against the Bears.) I don't think that the legacy is hard to deal with at all. It's just in his head. He could be an amazing quarterback, just like his brother, if he picks apart defe

CEC RILEY 03:11:00 PM Dec 04 2007

He doenst even act nor look like anyone i would want to follow..He looks like a KICKER with that ugly smug on his face,, He doesnt posses leadership. They will never win with him behind center. Tiki was right. they should have listened to him. Now Tiki is better off now and he can destroy Eli as a commentator and watch the Giants continue to LOOSE..

cindinduke 12:55:57 PM Dec 03 2007

People continually go back to when Eli was drafted and make a big deal out of it. It is done with, let it go. To keep reliving that doesn't do anything, but cloud the air, just as harping on the fact he is a Manning. Playing in New York, in any sport, is extrtemely difficult. Look at the year A-Rod had and still the fans are all over him because of his performance in the playoffs. You can't win with NY fans. The pressure is enormous. There is no other place like it. Yes, Eli has some problems, but he also has some real good qualities. He would be fine in most cities, but we have to have a Johnny Unitas, Tom Brady, etc. to be satisfied. We were never satisfied with Phil Simms until he took us to a Super Bowl. I would like to see the real fans get behind Eli instead of knocking his every move and every word that comes out of his mouth. Aikman said the kid is afraid to make a mistake. You can't play that way. He is it, so give him some leway and see what happens. We might

earlofkent01 07:28:38 PM Dec 02 2007

As a diehard Giants fan, I must say Eli sucks! He's had more excuses made for him than any other QB in the league. Phil Simms (though less talented) used his heart to get to the Hall of Fame. The pundits keeps saying that Eli is a Manning, thus he must be given a chance (more chances!) I do agree with the fact that he is a Manning; Archie Manning, certainly not Peyton Manning!

earlofkent01 07:17:35 PM Dec 02 2007

As a diehard Giants fan, I must say Eli's had more excuses made for him than any other quarterback in the NFL. I remember Phil Simms getting berated by the pundits; and I think it's obvious that Phil (though less talented) had more guts and far outplayed this kid. Everyone keeps referring to the fact that he is a Manning; to which I concur: Archie manning, not Peyton Manning!

jmdesoto 06:17:12 PM Dec 02 2007

Eli Manning thought he was to good to play for the Chargers and refused to go to them. I know the Chargers are glad he wound up in sucky NY. Manning as a rating of, is it 33 right now in the game..WOW.... how pathetic

jmdesoto 06:13:54 PM Dec 02 2007

I love the watch commercial,.."Eli Manning, Unstoppable..LOLOL" What a joke.

Giants SUCK. If they are lucky enough to make a wild card, they can come back to DAllas so we can destroy their ass and humiliate them again.